NAIA
-
Keegan Martin
2023 Winner
Friends University
-
Andrew Carter
2022 Winner
Carroll College
-
Matt Dey
2021 Winner
Dickinson State (N.D
-
Dustin Rivera
2020 Winner
Southwestern College
-
Dustin Rivera
2019 Winner
Southwestern College (Kan.)
-
Garrett Bader
2018 Winner
Benedictine College
-
Xavier Carter
2017 Winner
Reinhardt University
-
Brian Gegner
2016 Winner
University of Saint Francis
-
Zachary Mitchell
2015 Winner
Marian University
-
David Stochlin
2014 Winner
Benedictine College (Kansas)
-
Marc Osborn
2013 Winner
Grand View University
-
Matt Munizzi
2012 Winner
Saint Xavier University
-
Kyle Pettit
2011 Winner
Georgetown College
-
Andy Fjeseth
2010 Winner
Carroll College
-
Jeff Hynes
2009 Winner
Lindenwood University
-
Jeff Hynes
2008 Winner
Lindenwood University
-
Truman Ashby
2007 Winner
Benedictine College
-
Jeremiah Hays
2006 Winner
Evangel University
-
Kyle Baker
2005 Winner
Carroll College
-
Adam Sherman
2004 Winner
St. Francis
-
Dominic Miraglia
2003 Winner
Northwestern Oklahoma State